Here's a lovely little article from the "History Magazine" (and free to access to non-subscribers! W00t!) all about fact and fiction in historical films, namely in both
Elizabeth and
The Golden Age.
Linky linky: Hollywood Blockbusters and Historical RealityIt was published in September 2008, so is fairly recent, and written by Michael Mulloch, who is a teacher at Shrewsbury School.
This article does well in that it both defends historical movies (and tv shows) with all their inaccuracies, whilst also taking the time to point out the many errors in the
Elizabeth films and correct them, though not without opinions being given for the reasons for such "errors" being made. (The author also does well in explaining why TGA is somewhat inferior to
Elizabeth, something which I've felt is true for a while, but have not been able to fathom why - beside the fact that Walsie is rather too bumbling for my liking in TGA.)
Overall, I think it's nice to have an article which dispels the "myths" the
Elizabeth films have possibly created (if you haven't picked up a history book, or even consulted Wikipedia, since watching them). It also makes one realise how much of an "historical remix" (my new favourite phrase!) both the films are. (But then, so is
Quills, and we won't even get started on
Shakespeare in Love.)
As you all know, I'm quite happy to watch factually inaccurate films since I have no problem with going to read a book afterwards and proceeding to separate fact from fiction. Films are usually the catalyst which set me on the path to research so I owe them a lot - even Ray Winstone's trashy
Henry VIII (2003) left me with something! :D The only historical series I can't abide is
The Tudors. I watched series 1, don't get me wrong, and it is entertaining enough, but it doesn't even try remotely to resemble historical figures, fashions or facts. I see purpose in the way
Elizabeth was crafted, I can tolerate the modern-ness of the BBC's
The Virgin Queen (2005) because it still retains the basic skeleton of historical fact, but
The Tudors...? My God...
Mills and Boon on-screen. I can't believe it was penned by the writer of
Elizabeth! I guess the directors and producers do not share the beautiful, epic vision of Shekhar Kapur.
But I digress. Enjoy!
--x-posted to
geoffrey_rush